Any Traffic Please Advise - Inbound Radio Calls
by Russell Still
If you happen to frequent the forums at AOPA or
studentpilot.com, you've probably seen the long drawn-out
diatribes about proper radio phraseology. In most cases, we
have folks with maybe just little too much time on their
hands. The forums have become a hotbed for discontent it
seems.
As you know, in flight an occasional slang term slips in
like "no joy" or "here's the flash" or "in the box". I'm
going to be 100% honest with you and say that although these
aren't correct, I have absolutely no problem with them. None
whatsoever. Many times, the substitution of a well-known
slang term actually improves the information exchange that
must occur on the radio. But the folks in the forum
discussions rant and rave on, sticking to the inerrable
gospel of the AIM. It seems to have become a huge, well,
contest about who can quote the FARAIM the best.
Remember that FARs are regulatory. They are mandatory and
their strict interpretation should be used at all times. The
AIM, however, is a suggestion of what the Washington-types
want us to do in a perfect world. What does that mean?
Pretty much it says, "We're not giving this the power of
law, but we do think this is the best way to do it." Now if
you ever get yourself into trouble and it turns out that you
were operating contrary to the AIM, you can't say, "But I
thought it was just a suggestion." Saying "no joy" instead
of "negative traffic", though, isn't likely to get you into
any trouble.
No one is hurt one bit if a pilot responds to the the
controller "3217 in the box". And I doubt that anyone even
cares except for the internet forum purists who love so much
to quibble.
There IS one non-standard radio call that I do have a
problem with. Imagine that you're sitting in the pattern
with another aircraft, an inbound or outbound transitioning
through every few minutes. On your radio you hear the guy
call out, "Saratoga 873 Whiskey Mike, inbound from the
north. Any traffic in the area please advise."
Any traffic please advise. Nothing is more sure to raise the
ire of the radio purists than that phrase. And although not
with their fervency, I do agree with them. Turns out the FAA
agress with them, too.
One of the changes that has appeared in the 2007 AIM is in
section 4-1-9(g).
Allow me to quote it for you:
"Self-announce is a procedure whereby pilots broadcast
their position or intended flight activity or ground
operation on the designated CTAF . . . Pilots stating
'Traffic in the area please advise' is not a recognized
Self-Announce Position and/or Intention phrase and should
not be used under any condition."
Although they need to work on their grammar a little, their
message is clear. The habit of using this call has become a
big enough problem that the FAA felt it needed to address
it.
Asking traffic already in the airport area to advise YOU of
their positions is totally backwards. The system works when
each pilot volunteers that information. Inbound pilots need
to LISTEN on the traffic frequency well before they enter
the area. If they do that, they won't need to be advised of
anything. They'll already know it.
When entering any airport area, controlled or uncontrolled,
always volunteer your position and intentions. Tell them who
you are, where you are, and what you're planning on doing.
For the "where you are" part, give them your DDA. Distance,
direction, and altitude.
So often, I'll hear pilots pipe in with an otherwise good
self-announce, but they fail to say their altitude. That is
a critical piece of information for other pilots. No one
likes to trade paint. Please remember - distance, direction,
and ALTITUDE.
Now, if you're approaching a towered airport, get the ATIS
and give them your DDAA. Note that extra "A" there. Tell the
tower your distance, direction, altitude, and the ATIS
letter. Again, the altitude is important. Not only does it
help other pilots in your vicinity know where to look for
you, but it helps radar operators pick you out from the
clutter of other 1200s.
A proper call when inbound to a towered field might sound
like, "Graham Tower, Cessna 12345, 9 miles south, 2,800 with
Delta. Landing."
Get all these components in your calls and you will become
an active part in making airport airspaces safer places to
fly. And banish "any traffic please advise" from your
lexicon.
|